DickersonBakker Blog

donor retention definition

Donor Retention Definition: What Is It & Why Is It Important?

Donor retention is a critical aspect of nonprofit management, highlighting the importance of keeping existing donors engaged over time. It's not just about securing initial donations; it's about building lasting relationships that result in continued support. 

Learning more about donor retention definition and effective strategies to increase it can help your nonprofit reach its goals and maximize fundraising efforts. Keep reading to learn why. 

Donor Retention Definition: An Overview

Donor retention refers to the actions and strategies implemented by organizations to keep their current donors engaged and committed. In simpler terms, it is the process of maintaining a positive relationship with donors to ensure they continue to support the cause over an extended period. 

Donor retention is crucial for non-profits as it not only ensures a steady stream of funding but also allows for deeper connections with donors, leading to potential long-term partnerships. It requires continual effort and communication from non-profits to show appreciation, demonstrate impact, and build trust with donors. By focusing on donor retention, organizations can create a loyal donor base that is invested in their mission and drives sustainable growth for their cause.

Why Tracking Retention is Important for Donor Data

The Q3 2023 Fundraising Effectiveness Report reveals a 7.6% decline in overall donor numbers, alongside a 1.3% reduction in total donation amounts. 2023 represents the third consecutive year of declining donor numbers, a trend that is cause for concern.

DickersonBakker’s annual study of nonprofit leaders and staff indicated that 7% of respondents have no idea what their organization values most as a measure of fundraising health. Among those who do, gross revenue growth is by far the most common metric.

However, 45% of respondents showed donor retention as the metric that organizations should value most. 

Tracking donor retention provides valuable insights into the effectiveness of fundraising strategies, helps identify areas for improvement, and ultimately contributes to a sustainable funding model. Understanding and improving donor retention rates can significantly impact an organization's ability to achieve its mission and make a lasting difference.

Calculating Donor Retention Rate

The formula for calculating the donor retention rate is as follows:

  • Retention rate = (donors that gave this year ÷ donors that gave last year) x 100 (expressed as a percentage)

The retention rate of donors often differs among various nonprofit sectors. Analyzing existing reports to grasp these trends can provide valuable insights, allowing you to gauge how your nonprofit compares to the average retention rate within your specific sector.

Why Does Donor Retention Rate Matter?

Donor retention rate is a crucial aspect of the world of nonprofit organizations. We’ve outlined the top reasons why. 

Risk of Higher Attrition Rate

The success of your nonprofit largely depends on consistent financial support from donors. A low donor retention rate means you are at risk of losing these valuable supporters, which can lead to a decrease in funding and potentially harm the sustainability of your organization. 

By understanding the average retention rate in your sector, you can identify areas for improvement and work towards increasing donor loyalty. This not only ensures a stable stream of revenue but also establishes a strong base of committed donors who can contribute to your organization's long-term success.

Donor Satisfaction and Relationship Building

A high donor retention rate indicates that your donors are satisfied with your organization and its mission. By focusing on retaining existing donors, you can build stronger relationships with them, leading to increased loyalty and potential for future donations. This also helps in creating a positive image of your organization, which can attract new donors and increase fundraising efforts.


Acquiring new donors can be costly, both in terms of time and resources. By prioritizing donor retention, you can save money by not having to constantly find new donors. Moreover, loyal donors may also be more likely to give larger donations over time, making them a valuable investment for your organization.

Insight into Donor Behavior

By analyzing donor retention rates, nonprofits can gain valuable insights into donor behavior and preferences. For instance, a high retention rate indicates that donors are satisfied with the organization's mission and impact, while a low retention rate may suggest issues with communication or engagement strategies. Nonprofits can use this information to make informed decisions about their fundraising efforts and improve their relationships with donors.

The Recapture Rate for Lost Donors is Low

One of the main reasons for the low recapture rate for lost donors is a lack of donor retention strategies within nonprofit organizations. Many nonprofits focus solely on acquiring new donors, rather than prioritizing the retention of existing donors. This can lead to a constant cycle of losing and regaining donors, which ultimately hinders the overall growth and sustainability of an organization.

Donor retention is crucial because it not only helps maintain a stable stream of revenue but also fosters long-term relationships between donors and organizations. When donors feel appreciated and valued by an organization, they are more likely to continue supporting it in the future. This eliminates the need for constantly trying to win back lost donors and allows nonprofits to focus their efforts on building upon existing donor relationships.

Improved ROI

While acquiring new donors is important, maintaining a high donor retention rate can have a significant impact on the financial stability and sustainability of an organization. This is because retaining existing donors requires fewer resources and expenses compared to acquiring new ones. By cultivating strong relationships with donors and keeping them engaged, non-profits can reduce costs associated with fundraising and marketing efforts, ultimately leading to higher returns on investment.

Best Donor Retention Strategies to Enhance Retention Rates

Donor retention hinges on several key elements, one of which is ensuring you're reaching out to the right audience from the start. To enhance donor retention rates, consider these effective strategies:

  • Regular communication and updates on the impact of donations
  • Personalized thank you notes and acknowledgment
  • Exclusive events or experiences for donors
  • Offering volunteer opportunities
  • Providing regular progress reports on projects and programs
  • Creating a sense of community among donors through social media or online platforms
  • Implementing a donor loyalty program with rewards or incentives
  • Building relationships with donors through storytelling and showcasing the impact of their contributions

Build Your Fundraising Strategy With Donor Retention in Mind

In today's competitive nonprofit landscape, it is crucial to not only attract new donors but also retain existing ones. That’s why knowing the ins and outs of donor retention definition and learning strategies is crucial for achieving your goals. 

At DickersonBakker, we believe in Advancing Nonprofits™ through effective donor retention. If you need help getting started or have questions about our fundraising solutions, reach out anytime

Back to blog