DickersonBakker Blog

why are universities losing donors

Why Are Universities Losing Donors? Donor Retention Tips for Higher Ed

Universities have encountered increasing difficulties in maintaining their donor base, a crucial support for educational progress and student achievement. Fiscal year 2023 saw a modest 2.7% increase in contributions from organizations, encompassing foundations, donor-advised funds, and corporations, as per the reports. In total, these organizations donated $37.5 billion to higher education institutions.

Individual contributions, meanwhile, saw a decline. Fiscal 2023 witnessed an 11.1% decrease in donations from alumni, amounting to $12 billion, compared to the previous year. Similarly, non-alumni donations dropped by 10.5%, reaching a total of $8.5 billion in the same timeframe.

As the competition for donor dollars intensifies, higher ed institutions must understand the underlying reasons for universities losing donors and implement strategic measures to maintain and nurture their donor base. 

Why Do Universities Need Donor Support?

Universities are institutions of higher education that play a crucial role in shaping the future of our society. They provide students with knowledge, skills, and opportunities that prepare them for their careers and contribute to the growth and progress of our communities. 

However, running a university is no easy feat. It requires significant financial resources to maintain quality facilities, hire expert faculty, and support innovative programs. This is where donor support becomes essential. Here are some reasons why universities need donor support:

  • Tuition fees cover only a portion of university expenses, leaving a funding gap that donors can help bridge.
  • Donated funds can be used to improve facilities, technology, and infrastructure on campus, providing students with better learning environments.
  • Donor support can also fund scholarships and grants, making higher education more accessible and affordable for students from diverse backgrounds.
  • With donor support, universities can attract top faculty members who can enhance the quality of education and research at the institution.
  • Donors' contributions can also fund innovative programs and initiatives that promote interdisciplinary learning, critical thinking skills, and real-world experience for students.

Universities heavily rely on donations from alumni, corporations, and other philanthropic individuals to continue providing high-quality education. Without this support, universities would struggle to keep up with rising costs and maintain their standards of excellence. Donor contributions help bridge the gap between tuition fees and actual expenses, making higher education more accessible and affordable for students from all backgrounds. 

In short, universities need donor support to thrive and continue fulfilling their vital role in society as centers of learning and progress.

Main Reasons Why Donors Pull Their Money From Universities

There can be many reasons why a university donor stops contributing to the organization. Here are some of the top ones. 

Too Much Solicitation 

One of the main reasons a university donor may choose to stop contributing to their alma mater or institution is due to too much solicitation. Constantly bombarding donors with requests for donations, especially if they have already made multiple contributions in the past, can become overwhelming and even off-putting. Donors may start to feel like they are being taken advantage of or that their contributions are not valued, leading them to question the effectiveness and integrity of the university's fundraising efforts

Additionally, excessive solicitation can also be seen as a lack of stewardship towards donors, as it shows a disregard for their time and resources. This can ultimately result in donors choosing to redirect their contributions towards other causes or organizations where they feel appreciated and less inundated with donation requests. 

It is important for universities to strike a balance between soliciting donations and maintaining a positive relationship with their donors in order to prevent donor fatigue and ensure long-term support for their institution.

Asking for Too Much Money

A university relies heavily on the support of its donors to fund various initiatives and projects. However, there are situations where a donor may decide to stop contributing due to being asked for too much money. This can happen when the university continually increases its funding requests without showing tangible results or an effective plan for utilizing the funds. 

Donors want to feel that their contributions are making a positive impact and bringing about meaningful change. If they feel like their money is not being used efficiently or effectively, they may start questioning the university's intentions and lose trust in the institution. 

If a donor is continuously asked for large sums of money, it can become financially burdensome for them, especially if they have other financial commitments. As a result, they may decide to stop contributing altogether, which could have significant consequences for the university's financial stability and reputation. Universities must fulfill their funding needs while ensuring that donors feel valued and appreciated for their contributions.

The University Changed Leadership

One factor that could potentially lead a donor to stop contributing is a change in university leadership. This could be due to various reasons such as conflicting ideologies, differences in management style, or simply not resonating with the new leader's vision for the university. Whatever the reason may be, a shift in leadership can cause uncertainty and instability within the university community, which may ultimately deter donors from continuing their contributions. 

Donors want to see their investments make a positive impact on the institution they support, and any change that disrupts this can lead them to withdraw their support. Therefore, it is crucial for universities to carefully consider how leadership changes may affect their loyal donors and strive to maintain open communication and transparency during these transitions.

The Donor’s Financial Situation Changed

It’s not uncommon for a university donor's financial situation to change due to unforeseen circumstances such as job loss, health issues, or other financial obligations. In such cases, the donor may be forced to redirect their funds towards their personal needs and may no longer have the means to continue their contributions. 

This decision can be difficult for both the donor and the university, but, understandably, an individual's financial well-being should take priority over philanthropy in times of hardship.

What is the Best Way to Keep University Donors In It For the Long Run?

As universities heavily rely on donations from alumni and other donors, it’s important to develop strategies to retain their support long-term. Retaining university donors not only ensures a steady flow of financial support but also strengthens the bond between the institution and its community.

  • Cultivate personalized relationships: Building personal connections with donors through regular communication and updates can help foster a sense of loyalty towards the university.
  • Show appreciation: Donors want to feel valued and appreciated for their contributions. Expressing gratitude through social media, thank you letters, events, or naming opportunities can go a long way in retaining their support.
  • Involve them in meaningful ways: Universities can involve donors in various activities such as volunteering opportunities, mentoring programs, or advisory boards. This not only keeps them engaged but also makes them feel like they are making a difference
  • Keep them informed: Sharing impact reports and success stories with donors can show them how their contributions are making a positive impact on the university's mission. This can motivate them to continue supporting the institution. 

By implementing these retention strategies, universities can build strong and lasting relationships with their donors, ensuring sustainable financial support for years to come.

Increase Donor Retention With These Tips

Navigating the complexities of donor engagement and retention is paramount for universities seeking to secure their financial future and continue their mission of education and innovation. Understanding the reasons behind donor attitudes and addressing these concerns with strategic and thoughtful approaches is essential. 

DickersonBakker stands as a vital resource for higher education organizations aiming to optimize their fundraising strategies. With a deep understanding of the philanthropic landscape and a commitment to fostering meaningful relationships between universities and their donors, DickersonBakker provides the expertise and tools necessary to enhance donation efforts and ensure the ongoing success of educational institutions. Contact us today to learn more!

Back to blog